Allen Edmonds Men's McAllister Wing Tip

4.3 4.3 out of 5 stars 164 ratings

To see product details, add this item to your cart. You can always remove it later.
:
*

Free 7-day try-on available for some sizes and colors.
Free shipping & returns.
Learn more

Black
Size Chart
US Shoe size
Brand SizeUKEurope
65.539
6.5639.5
76.540
7.5741
87.541.5
8.5842
98.543
9.5943.5
109.544
10.51044.5
1110.545
11.51145.5
1211.546
12.51247
1312.548
141349
151450
To buy, select Size
Added to

Sorry, there was a problem.

There was an error retrieving your Wish Lists. Please try again.

Sorry, there was a problem.

List unavailable.

From the manufacturer

Allen Edmonds Port Washington
McAllister

The McAllister Wingtip Oxford

Handcrafted in Port Washington, WI, with premium European calfskin leather, the recraftable McCallister wingtip oxford is built on our original 360 Goodyear Bench Welt, providing stability and our legendary lasting comfort. Detailed pinking, perforations and medallion work create a beautiful, intricate wingtip design on this classic lace up oxford. Traditional style blended with a modern vibe, the McAllister looks fresh and polished when paired with suits and dress pants, as well as with jeans and a jacket.

"The McAllister's fit perfectly right out of the box and were very comfortable right from the start." - Alfred

A+ Content
Size Chart

Find the Right Size

What makes Allen Edmonds shoes so unique is the extensive range of sizes and widths we offer that make achieving a perfect fit much simpler. Each half size increases by approximately one-sixth of an inch and each full size increases by one-third of an inch. The widths of Allen Edmonds shoes range from AAA, the narrowest width, to EEE, the widest width, with a D width considered medium. Technically speaking, each width increases by approximately three-sixteenths of an inch in total girth.

Product Description

The McAllister wing tip from Allen Edmonds exudes stylish sophistication. With its rich leather upper, classic styling, and distinguished perforation detail, this shoe will add the perfect polish to your dress wardrobe. Dust bag included. Founded in 1922, Allen-Edmonds Shoe Corporation manufactures premium men's footwear, accessories, and cedar products using the philosophy of quality, service and integrity. Taking shoemaking to the level of an art form, each pair of Allen-Edmonds shoes are carefully crafted by hand in a process that includes 212 separate production steps. No detail is too small, because supreme quality is the cornerstone of the Allen-Edmonds name. Recraftable

The McAllister wing tip from Allen Edmonds exudes stylish sophistication. With its rich leather upper, classic styling, and distinguished perforation detail, this shoe will add the perfect polish to your dress wardrobe. Dust bag included.

Looking for specific info?

Product details

  • Product Dimensions ‏ : ‎ 12 x 8 x 4 inches; 1 Pounds
  • Item model number ‏ : ‎ MCALLISTR
  • Department ‏ : ‎ mens
  • Date First Available ‏ : ‎ April 28, 2009
  • Manufacturer ‏ : ‎ Allen Edmonds
  • ASIN ‏ : ‎ B001TDKWPK
  • Customer Reviews:
    4.3 4.3 out of 5 stars 164 ratings

Customer reviews

4.3 out of 5 stars
4.3 out of 5
164 global ratings

Customers say

Customers like the quality, appearance and versatility of the shoes. For example, they mention that it's a great looking shoe, the color is rich and tasteful, and that it fits true to size. That said, some complain about the comfort and scratch resistance. Opinions are mixed on fit and value.

AI-generated from the text of customer reviews

62 customers mention52 positive10 negative

Customers like the quality of the shoes. They mention that the stitching is fine, the shoes are solid built, and the workmanship is awesome. They also appreciate the attention to detail and the quality leather. Customers say that the shoes should last a lifetime with proper care.

"...18 month update - these remain my favorite shoes. They've held up exceptionally well with just occasional polishing." Read more

"...the great American shoe company and these shoes are a testament to fine American craftsmanship...." Read more

"...best investments in myself that I have ever made...These shoes are so well made, and of such quality, that they even come with shoe bags!..." Read more

"...The leather is thick and high quality. Use Allen Edmonds' shoe polish for best results.The walnut is my favorite color...." Read more

43 customers mention30 positive13 negative

Customers are mixed about the fit of the shoes. Some mention that they fit like a glove, while others say that they are tight on the width.

"...these shoes I'm very pleased with the way they've held up and how comfortable they are...." Read more

"...leather soles quietly click beneath you and the cork inner soles conforms perfectly to your feet providing the utmost in comfort...." Read more

"...from Zappo's as they weren't available here, and they were still too narrow...." Read more

"Shoe runs half size large. This shoe fits me perfect at 9D. My foot is a true 9.5D. I wear a 9.5D in Cole Haan (with dress socks): Lunargrand..." Read more

33 customers mention33 positive0 negative

Customers are satisfied with the appearance of the shoes. They mention that they are great looking, have great quality, and style. The color is rich and tasteful, making them the perfect dress shoe. The wingtip design is a timeless design, and the leather is beautiful. The shoes are very modern and a great addition to anyone's wardrobe.

"...I have to say, that when I dress up, and I put on these shoes, I look so good, I feel "...too damp to burn!"..." Read more

"...Both look great, a very versatile shoe and a great addition to anyone's wardrobe.Collection consists of 10+ pairs of Allen Edmonds." Read more

"...I wore them with a suit, but these shoes look great with a pair of chinos or even some jeans. The leather is great quality...." Read more

"...The leather although beautiful, is very stiff and required 4-5 occasions of wear to "break them in." Even after said break in period, I feel..." Read more

5 customers mention5 positive0 negative

Customers like the versatility of the shoes. They say it looks great dressed up with a suit or dressed down with merlot color.

"...Both look great, a very versatile shoe and a great addition to anyone's wardrobe.Collection consists of 10+ pairs of Allen Edmonds." Read more

"...I wore them with gray pants and I must say that is a terrific combination. I am very happy. :)" Read more

"The shoes are great, but Allen Edmonds shoes are insanely uncomfortable...." Read more

"Great versatile shoe - looks great dressed up with a suit or dressed down with some chinos..." Read more

4 customers mention4 positive0 negative

Customers appreciate the attention to detail and the quality of the leather. They also appreciate the extra perf details throughout the shoe.

"...colored trim piece on the rim of the entrance to the shoes, very subtle detail, but adds contrast and balance to the overall look...." Read more

"...Style wise these are my perfect wingtip. I dig the extra perf details throughout the shoe. This shoe is solid feeling...." Read more

"...These are the finest pair of shoes I have owned. The attention to detail and the quality of the leather are second to none. I love these shoes...." Read more

"...The craftsmanship is incredible with great attention to detail...." Read more

14 customers mention9 positive5 negative

Customers are mixed about the value of the shoes. Some mention that they are the best shoes money can buy, with great quality for the price. However, some customers feel the shoes are expensive and not worth it.

"...Had them on time to the west coast from Louisville KY. Amazon prices are great too, got these for more $100 dollars less than retail after tax." Read more

"...These are a fine choice. I love the wing tip style and perforations pattern. GREAT SHOES!" Read more

"...I didn't need to break them in at all. The price on these may seem expensive, but this is a shoe you can resole for a few bucks and it should last a..." Read more

"...Good price on amazon. Looks like I'll be in the Allen Edmonds market in the future...." Read more

5 customers mention0 positive5 negative

Customers are dissatisfied with the comfort of the shoes. They mention that the shoes are uncomfortable and stiff.

"...Further these never got as comfortable as I thought they should be...." Read more

"...ALSO VERY stiff leather and hurts. Doesn't feel like a $350 shoe...." Read more

"The shoes are great, but Allen Edmonds shoes are insanely uncomfortable...." Read more

"I love the design, but not comfortable at all.I will be more careful about sizes when I buy this brand online." Read more

5 customers mention0 positive5 negative

Customers are dissatisfied with the scratch resistance of the shoes. They mention that the edge dressing looks like it could chip off easily, the heel started peeling off within a month, and the soles have no traction.

"...a bit concerned about the edge dressing on these as it looks like it could chip off easily, it had on one of the other pairs of shoes.***..." Read more

"...at the point where it meets the side of teh shoe and the heal is visibly split!..." Read more

"Great item but soles have no traction and Leather scratches easily. I don't see these lasting long given the price this is disappointing" Read more

"Total ripoff. These shoes are horribly uncomfortable. The heel started peeling off within a month. Had to return them...." Read more

Quality shoes. Don't overthink it.
5 Stars
Quality shoes. Don't overthink it.
I was hesitant to spend this much on a pair of shoes. What I had in mind was half the price. I thought I could find similar quality shoes for the price I spent 15yrs ago. Not happening. The workmanship on these shoes is awesome. They fit true to my size. Fit was comfortable snug. I'm still in the break in process as this is the second week. Been wearing them full days and my feet do not hurt end of day. I'm really looking forward to when they have formed to my feet. I'm guessing maybe another month? Will not overthink my next Allen Edmonds purchase. Plan on buying another pair soon.
Thank you for your feedback
Sorry, there was an error
Sorry we couldn't load the review

Top reviews from the United States

Reviewed in the United States on December 4, 2011
Size: 10 D USColor: BlackVerified Purchase
7 people found this helpful
Report
Reviewed in the United States on December 3, 2013
Size: 9 D USColor: BlackVerified Purchase
9 people found this helpful
Report
Reviewed in the United States on December 11, 2012
Size: 13Color: WalnutVerified Purchase
20 people found this helpful
Report
Reviewed in the United States on February 11, 2017
Size: 9.5 D USColor: BlackVerified Purchase
11 people found this helpful
Report
Reviewed in the United States on December 12, 2014
Size: 9.5Color: WalnutVerified Purchase
7 people found this helpful
Report
Reviewed in the United States on March 5, 2014
Size: 8.5Color: WalnutVerified Purchase
8 people found this helpful
Report
Reviewed in the United States on July 27, 2015
Size: 8.5 D USColor: BlackVerified Purchase
2 people found this helpful
Report
Reviewed in the United States on August 23, 2019
Size: 9 D USColor: BlackVerified Purchase
2 people found this helpful
Report

Top reviews from other countries

Karl H.
5.0 out of 5 stars Not dainite soles as per pictures
Reviewed in Canada on May 19, 2023
Size: 9.5Color: WalnutVerified Purchase
Kim-Anh N.
5.0 out of 5 stars As described
Reviewed in Canada on December 19, 2019
Size: 8 D USColor: BlackVerified Purchase
Jean
5.0 out of 5 stars Excellent
Reviewed in Canada on August 15, 2020
Size: 8Color: BlackVerified Purchase
Brett Wills
5.0 out of 5 stars Five Stars
Reviewed in Canada on December 19, 2017
Size: 7.5 D USColor: WalnutVerified Purchase
Santa
3.0 out of 5 stars 2nd pair of Allen Edmonds purchased off of Amazon
Reviewed in Canada on February 15, 2019
Size: 7Color: BlackVerified Purchase
Customer image
Santa
3.0 out of 5 stars 2nd pair of Allen Edmonds purchased off of Amazon
Reviewed in Canada on February 15, 2019
My first pair of Allen Edmonds purchased on Amazon, there were blemishes but nothing too major to warrant a return. This is my 2nd purchase of Allen Edmonds shoes on here and I could confirm they are factory seconds. I will keep them as there is nothing major wrong with them.
Images in this review
Customer image Customer image Customer image Customer image Customer image Customer image
Customer imageCustomer imageCustomer imageCustomer imageCustomer imageCustomer image
2 people found this helpful
Report