Sam Edelman Women's Penny Classic Equestrian Boot

4.2 4.2 out of 5 stars 3,065 ratings

To see product details, add this item to your cart. You can always remove it later.
:
*

Free 7-day try-on available for some sizes and colors.
Free shipping & returns.
Learn more

Black Leather Wide Calf
Size Chart
US Equestrian Boots
Brand SizeEU SizeUK SizeHeel to toe (in)
43428.3
4.534.52.58.5
53538.7
5.53538.9
6363.59.1
6.536.549.3
7374.59.4
7.53859.6
838.55.59.8
8.539610
9406.510.2
9.540.5710.4
1041810.6
10.541810.8
1142911
11.542911.2
12431011.4
12.542.510.511.6
13431111.8
US Wide Equestrian Boots
Brand SizeEU SizeUK Size
4 Wide342
4.5 Wide34.52.5
5 Wide353
5.5 Wide353
6 Wide363.5
6.5 Wide36.54
7 Wide374.5
7.5 Wide385
8 Wide38.55.5
8.5 Wide396
9 Wide406.5
9.5 Wide40.57
10 Wide418
10.5 Wide418
11 Wide429
11.5 Wide429
12 Wide4310
12.5 Wide42.510.5
13 Wide4311
To buy, select Size
Added to

Sorry, there was a problem.

There was an error retrieving your Wish Lists. Please try again.

Sorry, there was a problem.

List unavailable.

From the manufacturer

wide calf fit

Product Description

Sam Edelman iconic knee-high riding boot in a wide shaft. If one foot is larger than the other, the measurements for the larger foot should be used.

Sam Edelman shoes epitomize chic comfort. With exceptional materials and fine styling, each pair of Sam Edelman shoes is an affordable luxury that cleverly combines a youthful outlook with a worldly sensibility. Sophistication with down-to-earth appeal mean that these shoes are made to be lived in. Whether it's a classic revisited for a modern interpretation or a cutting edge design, Sam Edelman shoes always keep an emphasis on comfort.

Looking for specific info?

Product details

  • Product Dimensions ‏ : ‎ 10 x 15 x 6 inches; 1.25 Pounds
  • Item model number ‏ : ‎ Penny
  • Department ‏ : ‎ womens
  • Date First Available ‏ : ‎ September 25, 2012
  • Manufacturer ‏ : ‎ Sam Edelman
  • ASIN ‏ : ‎ B007FNCMAG
  • Customer Reviews:
    4.2 4.2 out of 5 stars 3,065 ratings

Customer reviews

4.2 out of 5 stars
4.2 out of 5
3,065 global ratings

Customers say

Customers like the comfort and value of the boot. For example, they mention that it feels like nice soft leather, has a slim foot feel, and is well worth the price. Some appreciate the quality. That said, opinions are mixed on the zipper, fit, durability, and leather.

AI-generated from the text of customer reviews

840 customers mention809 positive31 negative

Customers are satisfied with the quality of the boot. They mention that it is a beautiful boot, the hardware looks elegant and understated, and the leather is soft and buttery. They also appreciate the brass detailing at the sides and back snap. Overall, customers are happy with their purchase and recommend it to others.

"...Overall, beautiful boot and I love the supple leather. Very elegant and simple with all the right touches...." Read more

"...They seem to be pretty good quality leather, and they feel very soft. I hate cheap-looking leather boots...." Read more

"...Other than the odd sizing, the boot was very nice looking and had soft, supple leather." Read more

"...Fortunately, the leather was not damaged. I may never order shoes through Amazon again." Read more

481 customers mention435 positive46 negative

Customers are satisfied with the comfort of the boot. They mention that the toe box provides perfect comfort, and the boot has a slim foot feel. They also appreciate the buttery leather and the snap cover for the zipper in back.

"...Comfortable enough for me to walk around in them for a full day. Looking forward to buying them in another color." Read more

"...I have worn these 7-8 times now and they have never hurt my feet or rubbed anywhere. Are they the most comfortable shoes I own? Well, no...." Read more

"...Other than the odd sizing, the boot was very nice looking and had soft, supple leather." Read more

"I just love this pair of boots. They are soft and super comfortable. I will buy them again." Read more

91 customers mention75 positive16 negative

Customers like the value of the boots. They mention that the construction at this price was unexpected, the price is super fair for real leather, and the quality is great for the price. Some say that the boots are expensive looking and the best boot investment ever.

"...bc they were exactly what I'd looked for...& I caught them at an amazing price. Ordered hoping they would fit as I need a wide calf...." Read more

"These boots are a strong choice for the pricepoint...." Read more

"...of the leather in this boot is very good,extremely soft and expensive looking...." Read more

"These are beautiful, and worth the money...." Read more

892 customers mention439 positive453 negative

Customers are mixed about the fit of the boot. Some mention that they fit perfectly, while others say that the fit is strange and the foot feels a little narrow.

"I ordered these boots in October of 2021. They were the perfect fit and fit my thick calves. These boots were my go to with dresses and leggings...." Read more

"...I also had too much heel slippage with the 9 1/2 but I do have slim heels. I have worn thin and thicker socks and they were still comfortable...." Read more

"The boots are beautiful, fit well and are well made...." Read more

"...They were a little too long (they seem to be long and narrow). My foot is a little on the narrow side, so the width was perfect...." Read more

173 customers mention91 positive82 negative

Customers are mixed about the durability of the boot. Some mention that the quality is full leather, sturdy, and heavy. The internal heel structure is nicely made, and the boot is very stable. However, others say that they seem fragile, and wish the quality was a little better. The leather is soft and does have some imperfections in it, but that is to be expected.

"The boots are beautiful, fit well and are well made...." Read more

"These are fake. I have another pair of the exact same boots and wanted a second pair because I love them. These boots are discolored...." Read more

"...In terms of quality, they seem well made and the leather is soft without being floppy...." Read more

"...The very first time, the snap on the back of the left calf fell apart. I can’t request a replacement because it’s past the return window. *..." Read more

112 customers mention47 positive65 negative

Customers are mixed about the zipper. Some love how they zip up the back instead of the insole, and appreciate the snap cover for the zipper in back. However, others say that the zippers are tough to zip all the way at the bottom, and barely zipped up.

"...I couldn’t get it zipped up all the way. The zippers are in the back which makes it much harder to zip up...." Read more

"...I hate cheap-looking leather boots. I like how the boot zips in the back, which makes wearing straight leg or skinny jeans easy...." Read more

"...The wide calf was extremely too wide and the regular calf I couldn’t get zipped. Was disappointed to send back but had too." Read more

"Loved the buttery leather and the snap cover for the zipper in back. I usually wear size 8. I purchased the black in size 8.5 M-WC...." Read more

99 customers mention65 positive34 negative

Customers are mixed about the leather. Some mention that the quality is very good, extremely soft, and expensive looking. They also appreciate that the boots are leather all over and don't have any big elastic panel. However, others say that the leather was not what they expected for this price, too thin to be considered durable, and has some inconsistencies.

"...than the odd sizing, the boot was very nice looking and had soft, supple leather." Read more

"...I love that they are leather all over and don't have any big elastic panel or anything giving away the fact that they are wide calf boots...." Read more

"...I'm happy with the quality of these boots. The leather isn't as soft as I expected, but for boots maybe thats a good thing...." Read more

"The quality of the leather in this boot is very good,extremely soft and expensive looking...." Read more

43 customers mention0 positive43 negative

Customers are dissatisfied with the appearance of the boot. They mention that the material looks cheap and stiff, the calf is much wider than their real boots, and the leather looks cheap in person. Some customers also mention that they are too plain for their taste, and that the loops on the side are purely decorative and not functional.

"...These boots are discolored. The material is cheap looking and stiff. The calf is much wider than my real boots. And the buckles do not stay closed...." Read more

"...I put them on and I looked ridiculous - like I'd grabbed a pair of my husband's boots by mistake. The calf was so oversized and floppy...." Read more

"...I had on thick socks, skinny jeans, and the ankle is wrinkly looking and my foot slides up and down when wearing...." Read more

"...I fee like they look kind of cheap and arent going to last very long...." Read more

Weird fit, snap fell apart first time I wore them
4 Stars
Weird fit, snap fell apart first time I wore them
These feel like good quality boots. The leather is very soft and feels really nice. The fit of the calves is really strange. I have larger calves and sometimes struggle to find boots that fit over them. These have a huge gap in the calves. I’m so glad I didn’t order the wide calf! The toe box and across the ball of my foot are really tight, so if you’re on the fence about ordering wide foot width, you probably should. So the calves are super wide and the foot bed is pretty narrow.These felt ok when I tried them on the day my order was delivered, but I waited over a month before I actually wore them out of the house. The very first time, the snap on the back of the left calf fell apart. I can’t request a replacement because it’s past the return window. *shrug* I’ll have to glue it together or take it to a local cobbler to have them repaired.
Thank you for your feedback
Sorry, there was an error
Sorry we couldn't load the review

Top reviews from the United States

Reviewed in the United States on January 6, 2016
Size: 9Color: BlackVerified Purchase
10 people found this helpful
Report
Reviewed in the United States on December 8, 2013
Size: 8Color: WhiskeyVerified Purchase
3 people found this helpful
Report
Reviewed in the United States on February 24, 2024
Size: 8Color: Black Leather Wide CalfVerified Purchase
Reviewed in the United States on September 30, 2023
Size: 6Color: Black Leather Wide CalfVerified Purchase
One person found this helpful
Report
Reviewed in the United States on January 7, 2024
Size: 5.5Color: Whiskey Leather Wide CalfVerified Purchase
Reviewed in the United States on December 15, 2023
Size: 8Color: Black Leather Wide CalfVerified Purchase
Reviewed in the United States on February 16, 2024
Size: 4Color: BlackVerified Purchase
Reviewed in the United States on February 14, 2024
Size: 7.5Color: Black Leather Wide CalfVerified Purchase

Top reviews from other countries

Amazon Customer
5.0 out of 5 stars Great quality boot
Reviewed in Canada on March 31, 2023
Shazzeryyc
5.0 out of 5 stars I couldn’t be more pleased!
Reviewed in Canada on October 13, 2022
Size: 8Color: Whiskey Leather Wide CalfVerified Purchase
Customer image
Shazzeryyc
5.0 out of 5 stars I couldn’t be more pleased!
Reviewed in Canada on October 13, 2022
Trying to buy “wide shaft” boots online can be a minefield. Often measurements are incorrect and descriptions are misleading. Not so this time!

I am 5’6” and have an athletic 16” calf. My normal shoe size is 8M and I have thick ankles. These boots fit me like a glove! The pictures show them with winter leggings tucked in. The elastic gore is unextended on my 16” calf, but I think it would easily expand to 17-18”. The leather is really soft and supple. I predict that they will conform to my foot and calf with wear. There is no lining.

As for foot sizing, I think these are just a little narrow for a winter boot. If you are between sizes I’d order up one and go for wide if you plan on using heavy socks.

The colour is a lovely traditional medium whiskey brown with toe shading.

Best buy I’ve made this season. These are a timeless classic boot.
Images in this review
Customer image Customer image Customer image
Customer imageCustomer imageCustomer image
4 people found this helpful
Report
Louise L.
5.0 out of 5 stars The boots are wide width and fit perfectly.
Reviewed in Canada on March 5, 2021
Sand
5.0 out of 5 stars Just what I have been looking for!
Reviewed in Canada on January 7, 2020
Size: 9Color: BlackVerified Purchase
6 people found this helpful
Report
N. Roy
5.0 out of 5 stars Good quality
Reviewed in Canada on November 13, 2019